| Round | Round | Round | Round | Round | Round | ||||||||
| Team | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | |||||||
| 1 | Stingrays | Rodriguez | Sea | Rolen | Stl | Yankees | PS | Konerko | CWS | Gonzalez | Tex | Wells | Tor |
| 2 | Oysters | Bonds | SF | Boone | Sea | Atlanta | PS | Hinske | Tor | Johnson | Col | Mondesi | NYY |
| 3 | Death | Garciaparra | Bos | Bagwell | Hou | Abreu | Phi | Kendall | Pit | Klesko | SD | Blalock | Tex |
| 4 | Hummers | Soriano | NYY | Suzuki | Sea | Glaus | Ana | Seattle | PS | Rollins | Phi | Lee | Fla |
| 5 | Victory | Giambi, Ja | NYY | Chavez | Oak | Burrell | Phi | Hernandez | Col | Bellhorn | ChC | Dye | Oak |
| 6 | Clippers | Pujols | Stl | Walker | Col | Boston | PS | Edmonds | Stl | Guzman | Min | Durazo | Oak |
| 7 | Destroyers | Helton | Col | Griffey | Cin | Gonzalez | Ari | Aurillia | SF | Lieberthal | Phi | Floyd | NYM |
| 8 | X-Men | Guerrero | Mon | Jones, C | Atl | LoDuca | LA | Alomar | NYM | Dunn | Cin | Biggio | Hou |
| 9 | Contributors | Ordonez | CWS | Beltran | KC | Oakland | PS | Wilson | Col | Castillo | Fla | Koskie | Min |
| 10 | Redbirds | Tejada | Oak | Ramirez | Bos | Sheffield | Atl | Palmiero | Tex | Houston | PS | Ramirez | Pit |
| 11 | Vipers | Piazza | NYM | Delgado | Tor | Hunter | Min | Jones, A | Atl | Beltre | LA | Furcal | Atl |
| 12 | Connection | Arizona | PS | Vidro | Mon | Damon | Bos | Eckstein | Ana | Alfonzo | SF | Stewart | Tor |
| 13 | Barracudas | Jeter | NYY | Sweeney | KC | Rodriguez | Fla | Spivey | Ari | White Sox | PS | Hillenbrand | Bos |
| 14 | Cobras | Berkman | Hou | Sosa | ChC | Posada | NYY | Cubs | PS | Boone, A | Cin | Valentin | CWS |
| 15 | Rebels | Kent | Hou | Green | LA | Dodgers | PS | Renteria | Stl | Sexson | Mil | Matsui | NYY |
| 16 | Blackjacks | Giles | Pit | Thome | Phi | Anderson | Ana | Williams | NYY | Durham | SF | Huff | TB |
| Order | Down | Up | Down | Up | Down | Up | |||||||
| Round | Round | Round | Round | Round | Round | ||||||||
| Team | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | |||||||
| 1 | Stingrays | Lee | CWS | Patterson | ChC | Hariston | Bal | Hudson | Tor | McGriff | LA | Hernandez | Oak |
| 2 | Oysters | Olerud | Sea | Erstad | Ana | Womack | Ari | Everett | Tex | Young, E | Mil | Conine | Bal |
| 3 | Death | St. Louis | PS | Catalanotto | Tor | Drew | Stl | Bautista | Ari | Thurston | LA | Cirillo | Sea |
| 4 | Hummers | Jones, J | Min | Gibbons | Bal | Garcia | Cle | Phelps | Tor | Larue | Cin | Uribe | Col |
| 5 | Victory | Marrero | Stl | Encarnacion | Fla | Cameron | Sea | Choi | ChC | Philly | PS | Rivas | Min |
| 6 | Clippers | Batista | Bal | Walker | Bos | Alou | ChC | Santiago | SF | Woodward | Tor | Larson | Cin |
| 7 | Destroyers | Kennedy | Ana | Ventura | NYM | Anaheim | PS | Nixon | Bos | Casey | Cin | Phillips | Cle |
| 8 | X-Men | Lowell | Fla | Larkin | Cin | San Fran | PS | Roberts | LA | Fick | Atl | Randa | KC |
| 9 | Contributors | Cabrera | Mon | Vaughn | NYM | Varitek | Bos | Wilkerson | Mon | Fullmer | Ana | Vazquez | SD |
| 10 | Redbirds | Winn | Sea | Ellis | Oak | Martinez | Sea | Barrett | Mon | Belliard | Col | Cruz | SF |
| 11 | Vipers | Vina | Stl | Hildalgo | Hou | Pierre | Fla | Gonzalez | ChC | Bell | Phi | Minnesota | PS |
| 12 | Connection | Hall | TB | Ibanez | KC | Byrd | Phi | Mientkiewicz | Min | Lugo | Hou | Tatis | Mon |
| 13 | Barracudas | Kearns | Cin | Payton | Col | Salmon | Ana | Martinez | Stl | Jordan | LA | Young, M | Tex |
| 14 | Cobras | Thomas | CWS | Burroughs | SD | Kotsay | SD | Burks | Cle | Hatteberg | Oak | Polanco | Phi |
| 15 | Rebels | Spiezio | Ana | Pierzynski | Min | Finley | Ari | Giambi, Je | Bos | Simon | Pit | Guillen | Sea |
| 16 | Blackjacks | Vizquel | Cle | Crede | CWS | Mora | Bal | Mets | PS | Lopez | Atl | Lawton | Cle |
| Order | Down | Up | Down | Up | Down | Up |